Message Board Thread - "Spyglass Viewport"

Back to Threads | Back to Forums

TitleByPosted On
Spyglass Viewport newguy 9/26/2006
Has anyone tried the "Spyglass Viewport" being offered by Micron?
If so what is your opinion of the product?
 
Re:Spyglass Viewport john@FLIR 9/28/2006
We often get asked about the plastic viewport approach to allow infrared inspection of electrical cabinets without opening the panel doors. The idea is that this approach makes it safer for thermographer to do inspections because they don’t have to open the doors.

While we support an approach that allows inspections to be done without opening the doors, we believe very strongly that this approach is dangerous to the thermographer and to anyone proximate to these panels. The panel doors are there for a reason, namely to protect people from hurting themselves and making the area safer in the event of an arc flash and/or explosion.

Putting an open hole in the panel door that’s
> ½” wide protected by nothing more than a plastic port and plastic cover defeats this safety mechanism. IEE regulation 412-03-01 that states, “Live parts shall be inside enclosures or behind barriers providing at least the degree of protection IP2X”. The 5/8” hole is in contravention of IP2X and can negate the safety rating of the cabinets.

A customer described how a person electrocuted themselves when they attempted to measure the distance from the door to the bus bar with a tape measure through a vent. As a result of incident like this, utilities are replacing doors with vents with fully protected enclosures.

In addition, the viewport approach requires a big and expensive proprietary lens to look through their 5/8” view hole. This means that anyone installing these view holes is locked into a single camera supplier forever. The lens can’t focus beyond 45” so it’s useless for any other applications.

We believe that IR windows accomplish the same goal in a much safer manner. Many even include a locking metal cover for further protection (IP65). Nothing can penetrate the cabinet and no safety ratings are compromised. In fact, many OEM cabinet makers are offering doors with the IR windows already installed.

While some customers feel they get better results with a wide angle lens, most have decided that it’s not necessary and that they can scan the entire cabinet by rotating a camera and standard lens. This is the safest, quickest, and most practical way to perform electrical cabinet inspections.

Regards,
John
1-800-GO-INFRA
 
Re:Spyglass Viewport MROHAN 9/30/2006
Hi Newguy!

We looked at the Spyglass and decided against it.

One of the major reasons was the lack of a visual inspection capability through the hole. We try to provide visual images for reference with every IR image - especially in an electrical panel where there are multiple components - as it makes the repair and retesting job simpler for our elecricians.

Second was the fact that the hole was large enough to poke a finger through giving no protection should an arc-flash occur and contravenes electrical equipment guidelines.

We decided on an IR inspection option that provided arc-flash protection and visual inspection capability in one.

Hope this helps!


Marty.
 


  • Back to Threads
  • Back to Forums

     

  •   Copyright © FLIR Systems, Inc 2012